Did you buy a new lot? Then you're also buying the illegal structures on it

Fleur

Landelijk paardenverblijf met te koop bord

Anyone who buys a parcel of land normally also acquires the structures located on it, including the associated compliance risks. A recent ruling by the Gelderland District Court has confirmed this once again.

Since 2021, a private individual has owned an agricultural parcel in the municipality of Maasdriel. He keeps goats and ponies there as a hobby. The plot contains a horse stable, a storage unit, a canopy, a manure storage area, light poles, a horse arena, and paved areas. These were largely constructed by the previous owner without the required environmental permits.

Following an enforcement request from the neighbors, the municipal executive imposed eight orders subject to a penalty payment. Seven of these orders required the removal of the structures and the paved area, and one required the removal of the animals.

The judge in preliminary relief proceedings first suspended the orders regarding the structures. In his view, the building ban under the Environmental Act could not be enforced against someone who did not construct the structures themselves.

However, the judge in the trial on the merits sees it differently. He points out that not only is building without a permit prohibited, but so is maintaining such a structure. Since the new owner of the lot is maintaining the illegal structures, he himself is in violation of the law.

The owner also argued (among other things) that the situation had existed for decades and the municipality had never taken action, but according to the trial judge, that did not make the enforcement disproportionate.

The trial judge therefore ruled that the appeal was unfounded and that the orders, subject to a penalty payment, remained in effect.

In practice, this means the following:

  • Under the Environment Act, the principle that applied under the Wabo remains in effect: even a person who maintains illegal structures that they did not build themselves can be held liable as an offender.
  • When purchasing a parcel of land, it is advisable to investigate the existing structures and the permitted use to avoid surprises in the future.
  • The fact that a structure has been on the property for years and the municipality was aware of it does not preclude (subsequent) enforcement.

Do you have questions about enforcement regarding illegal structures and/or the use of your property? Please contact Gerard van der Wende or me.

You can read the ruling here. 

Logo Haij Wende

De Haij & van der Wende

Lawyers
Dennis rond 200x200

Dennis Oud

Lawyer
Erwin rond 200x200

Erwin den Hartog

Corporate law, Real estate law
Fleur 1

Fleur Huisman

Environmental law
Petra lindhout pf

Petra Lindthout

Environmental law
Tessa rond 200x200

Tessa Sipkema

Employment law
Gerard rond 200x200

Gerard van der Wende

Administrative law and Family law
Elke 1

Elke Hofman-Bijvank

Employment law
Tim portret

Tim van Riel

Employment law
Iris portret

Iris Keemink

Lawyer
Noa Thumbnail

Noa Bilogrevic

Lawyer
Bekijk button

Possibly also of interest to you

Test news item

Please note that the content of our website (including any legal submissions) is for non-binding informational purposes only and does not serve as legal advice in the strict sense. The content of this site cannot and should not serve as a substitute for individual and binding legal advice relating to your specific situation. All information is therefore provided without guarantee of accuracy, completeness and timeliness.

Stay informed

Sign up for our newsletter